How to take progress photos worth comparing

Most progress photos are useless, and not because the person taking them is not making progress. Two photos taken in different light, at different distances, at different times of day are not comparable — the difference between them is mostly the conditions. Fixing that takes about five minutes of setup, once.

By the Dietly teamUpdated 6 min read

The reason to bother is that photos catch what other measurements miss. The scale cannot tell fat from muscle and is drowned in water weight day to day. A tape measure moves slowly. A photograph captures the thing you actually care about — but only if the photograph is the only variable that changed.

The six things to hold constant

1. One place, every time

Pick a spot with even, indirect light and a plain background. Overhead light is the worst case: it casts shadows down the abdomen that read as definition on a good day and vanish on a cloudy one. A window to the side, or a well-lit bathroom, beats a spotlight. Then mark where your feet go — tape on the floor is not excessive.

2. One camera position

Phone on a stable surface, lens at roughly navel height, about two metres back, held level rather than tilted. Camera height changes apparent proportions dramatically: shooting from above shortens the legs and slims the waist, shooting from below does the reverse. A timer or a voice shutter is better than handing the phone to someone who will stand somewhere different next month.

3. One time of day

First thing in the morning, after the bathroom, before eating or drinking. You look meaningfully different at 9pm than at 7am — food volume, water, sodium and glycogen all change how you appear, and none of it is fat.

4. The same three angles, relaxed

Front, side, back. Arms at your sides, standing normally. The temptation is to flex, and flexed photos are fine as an additional set — but a flex is a skill that improves with practice, so a flexed-only series will show progress that is partly just you getting better at flexing. The relaxed set is the honest one.

5. The same clothing

Minimal and fitted, showing the waistline. Loose clothing conceals the exact region where change shows up first.

6. The same interval

Weekly is a good cadence for capture. It is a bad cadence for judgement.

Shoot weekly, compare monthly

Real change over seven days is smaller than the variation from sleep, salt, carbohydrate intake and training soreness. Comparing this week to last week mostly measures noise, and the noise is demoralising in a way that has ended more diets than hunger has. Capture every week so you have the series, then compare against four to six weeks ago. That is where change becomes visible.

Why this matters more for photo-scored apps

If you are using an app that assigns a physique score to the photo, consistency stops being good practice and becomes the whole basis of the number. The model sees an image, not a body. Better light genuinely produces a better score without any change in you, and a different angle can cost several points. A scored series is only meaningful to the extent the conditions were identical.

Storing them so you actually keep them

Put them in one album, named by date. The most common failure is not bad photos, it is a series that stops after three weeks and a set of images scattered across a camera roll in no order. If you are six months in and want to see the change, you need the first one to still be findable.

Dietly does this part automatically — the weekly scan keeps the series, scores it out of 100 across leanness, definition, symmetry, posture, body fat and potential, and names the weak point that the next week of training is then built around. The setup above still matters; the app cannot fix a photo taken under a different lamp.

What to pair them with

Photos are one input. Two others cost nothing and fail differently, so together they tell you more than any one alone: a morning bodyweight averaged across the week, and a waist measurement at the navel taken fortnightly. If all three point the same way, that is signal. If they disagree, the disagreement is usually water, and the answer is to wait another fortnight rather than to change the plan.

References

  1. Heymsfield SB, et al. Digital anthropometry: a critical review. Eur J Clin Nutr, 2018.
  2. Bhutani S, et al. Composition of two-week change in body weight under unrestricted free-living conditions. Physiol Rep, 2017.

Not medical advice. This article is general information written by the Dietly team. It is not written or reviewed by a physician or a registered dietitian, and it knows nothing about your medical history. Speak to a qualified professional before making a significant change to how you eat or train — particularly if you are pregnant, under 18, or managing a health condition or an eating disorder.

Read next